Does the state have the right to redistribute wealth from some people to others? Obviously not. If you rented out houses for a living, would you like it if the government took one of your houses and gave it to a homeless person? Sure it helps that homeless person, but the government would be taking away your property! They don’t have the right to take your property. The government doesn’t have more rights than the people. If they can take someone’s things, that means we can. If the president told you to give him a million dollars, would you? I wouldn’t. I wouldn’t give money to someone unless I trust them, or I’m willing to loose that money. Never lend something that you are willing to loose.